Wednesday, September 27, 2017

Our FPTP System Has a Built-in Recall Election

Kind of. But it happens only when there's a general election. Given that politicians can inflict significant damage to our economy or take totally unpatriotic and completely stupid decisions like privatising water a lot faster voters need to be able to boot them out of office anytime between two general elections. So our excellent FPTP system should be improved by equipping it with standard recall elections -- something which Lalit suggested in early 2014.

We also need referendum legislation so our elected governments can ask for our permission on matters of national interest. For example Lepep campaigned against the Metro Leger but it is now proceeding with essentially the same unnecessary project. It should have organised a referendum to ask for our green light first. Same thing for the idiotic idea of privatising the CWA. It's nowhere to be found in their electoral manifesto. We never voted for it. Lepep cannot go ahead with that project before asking us what we think. We are not children. As they found out in Barkly recently.

Of course you realise that party lists and double candidacies are totally incompatible with recall elections. These two contraptions prevent us from deciding which politicians -- some might be inclined to shoot others -- we want to keep out of parliament. It's like a football game without a red card. Or one where selected players show a brown card to the referee to stay on the pitch after being shown a red one. Not a bad idea to make a list of the parties who are in favour of double candidacies so we can avoid them like the plague. Plus there's a by-election soon. So let's start: Rezistans ek Alternativ, ...

2 comments:

Rishi said...

“Standard” recall regulations should however be fool-proof. Otherwise, we run the risk of having seats invalidated for frivolous reasons and election campaign ongoing all over the year.
I do not quite agree with the idea that our current system is fitted with recall. We elect a government for a 5 year-term and it is compelled to organise elections after this mandatory period except for a few months of caretakership which extend its stay in power. There are also one-term MPs who are not fielded again at the next elections. The electorate is then not afforded the opportunity of booting them out.
In fact, referenda and recall are the best ways to ensure a healthy democracy because power rests permanently in the hands of people. Let’s also not forget that matters of national interest also concern electoral and judicial reforms such as abolishing the Best Loser System and creating institutions like a Prosecution Commission. These shall compulsorily go through referenda.

akagugo said...

"... power rests permanently in the hands of the people"

Or rather intermittently. Because nowadays, I wonder how many would actually be eager to press the 'Eject' button...